Re: MD A metaphysics

From: Scott R (
Date: Sat Sep 13 2003 - 18:04:41 BST

  • Next message: David MOREY: "Re: MD Four options"


    [Matt:] > When I say that the analogy hinges on an ocular metaphor, I mean
    that the representationalist takes the example and creates the existence of
    a metaphysical Eye, that recognizes Truth when it sees it, as analoguous to
    the physical eye we sense things with. That's why representationalists say
    the truth is "justified _true_ belief": they think that our special Eye
    tells us when a belief is true and not just justified. Pragmatists have no
    idea how this is done. They don't accept the analogy between a sensory eye
    and a metaphysical Eye.

    [Scott:] You may be interested that Coleridge sees bad philosophy (aka SOM)
    as coming about through what he calls "the despotism of the eye". While I
    think he would agree with the above, in that he does not hold with Truth as
    something "to be seen", actually (as in naive materialism -- what is real is
    what is perceivable) or analogically, he also rails against it for another
    reason. That is the tendency to simply give up thinking when the discussion
    moves to the non-visualizable.

    An example is the tendency to call quantum physics paradoxical, when it is
    not at all. The mathematics is perfectly consistent (as it must be to be
    mathematics). However, what we cannot do is visualize the goings on at the
    quantum level which the mathematics indicates, since visualization requires
    that things behave like particles or waves, but not both simultaneously,
    that they have precise locations and momenta, etc.

    Of course, he knew nothing of quantum mechanics, and what he had in mind is
    his law of polarity, which cannot be visualized because it involves
    self-contradictory identity. It requires, and indeed is, Imagination, in his
    use of the word.

    - Scott

    MOQ.ORG -
    Mail Archives:
    Aug '98 - Oct '02 -
    Nov '02 Onward -
    MD Queries -

    To unsubscribe from moq_discuss follow the instructions at:

    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Sat Sep 13 2003 - 18:24:47 BST